Rate The Ultimate Universe

[-beardoms-]

I've never seen anything like this on this board since i've been here, so thought i'd do one. Basically you have to list all the ultimate series in personal best to worst from top to bottom. So best at top, worst at bottom.

Ongoing:

Ultimate Spider-Man
Ultimate X-Men
Ultimate Fantastic Four

Limited:

Ultimates
Ultimates 2
Ultimate dardevil and Elektra
Ultimate Human
Ultimate Nightmare
Ultimate Secret
Ultimate Extinction
Ultimate Six
Ultimate Wolverine Vs Hulk
Ultimate Iron Man
Ultimate Origins
Ultimate Elektra
Ultimate War
Ultimate X4
UMTU
Ultimate X-Men/FF Annual
Ultimate FF/X-Men Annual
Ultimate Vision
Ultimate Iron Man II
Ultimate Adventures
Ultmate Captain America Annual
Ultimates 3
Ultimate Hulk Annual
Ultimate Power
Ultimatum

 

[E]

This seems difficult...Ultimate Spider-Man and Ultimate X-Men had moments of brilliance as well as polar opposites of crappiness. It's hard to rate the series as a whole next to something much smaller like Ultimate Wolverine vs. Hulk or even Ultimate Elektra. some parts were so much better they can't even be compared, and others were so bad they made Ultimate Iron Man look readable.

 

[The Overlord]

This seems difficult...Ultimate Spider-Man and Ultimate X-Men had moments of brilliance as well as polar opposites of crappiness. It's hard to rate the series as a whole next to something much smaller like Ultimate Wolverine vs. Hulk or even Ultimate Elektra. some parts were so much better they can't even be compared, and others were so bad they made Ultimate Iron Man look readable.

You still could rate the minis though.

 

[Mattimeo84]

or break it down by trade, that gives every arc about 5 issues to rate and compare

 

[fenway]

Here's my attempt

On-going:
Ultimate Fantastic Four (Millar's run of 12 issues)
Ultimate X-Men (BKV's stuff)
Ultimate Spider-Man (Early USM, Moon Knight, and Marvel Knights stuff)
rest of USM
rest of UXM
rest of UFF



Limited:

Ultimates
Ultimates 2
Ultimate Human
Ultimate Nightmare
Ultimate War
Ultimate Six
Ultimate Vision
Ultimate Wolverine Vs Hulk (would have been higher, but......you know)
Ultimate Extinction
UMTU
Ultimate Elektra
Ultimate dardevil and Elektra
Ultimate Secret
Ultmate Captain America Annual
Ultimate X4
Ultimate X-Men/FF Annual
Ultimate FF/X-Men Annual
Ultimate Origins
Ultimate Iron Man II
Ultimate Iron Man
Ultimate Power
Ultimates 3
Ultimatum
The time the anesthesia didn't take on the 'right side' of my vasectomy (not kidding)
Ultimate Hulk Annual

 

[fenway]

No one else is taking a shot?

(I want to see how far off I am from the general concensus )