The "Donnie Darko": Blueberry Crunch, filled with nuts, and an edible silver-leaf lining.
The "Lord of the Rings": ALL THE ICE CREAM.
The "Wet Hot American Summer": A giant banana split with scoops of red, white and blue ice cream from brands they don't make anymore, lit sparklers, a couple of cigarette butts, Jack Daniels, real beeswax honeycomb and grass clippings. It's not listed on the menu and has to be requested.
The "Beetlejuice": Plain vanilla on top, tropical sorbet underneath. And lots of those licorice spider thingies.