Superman sez: all criminals are bad. All lawbreakers deserve punishment. If Superman were in charge of the DEA, roughly 70% of college students across the country would be serving time in prison right now.
Superman has no values of his own, so he's content to just uphold the values of the ruling class;
Bats comes up against a young boy holding a gun on him. Batman, understanding the complexity of crime and the reasons for its existence, talks the kid into dropping the gun and giving up a life of violence.
Superman would probably just use his heat-vision to melt the gun, then put the kid in prison where he'd become a hard-bitten thug who'd murder somebody a few months after getting out.
If anything Batman is my favourite, with Superman either tied or EXTREMELY close and Spider-Man not far behind either.
But that doesn't make "This sucks because that is better" anything resembling a debate tactic. Especially when all your other points are baseless nonsense that's far more dependant on the writer than the character.