Battle Of The Comic Book Writers

[moonmaster]

Brian Michael Bendis
Mark Millar
Frank Miller
BKV
Grant Morrison
Neil Gailman
Alan Moore
Garth Ennis

 

[ProjectX2]

I think Moore is going to win this overall... I'm amazed at how Nur says certain things suck yet he hasn't read things from the greatest writers. Gaiman, Morrison and Moore! Damn you Nur!

Brian Michael Bendis (Claremont sucks more than Bendis...)
Mark Millar (He's Scottish...)
JMS (Only Miller thing I like is Sin City...)
BKV (This guy is cool...)
Grant Morrison (This guy is weird, like me...)
Neil Gailman (1602 is a great story...)
Alan Moore (LOEG is a great comic....)
Joss Whedon (Astonishing X-Men is cool...)

 

[iceman]

Brian Michael Bendis
Mark Millar
Frank Miller
BKV
Grant Morrison
Neil Gailman
Alan Moore (i agree with the curbstomp statement. moore should win this tourney easily.)
Garth Ennis

 

[thee great one]

How I predict the final rounds going

Quarter finals

Millar Beats Bendis

Miller Beats Busiek

Morrison Beats Gaiman

Moore Beats Waid

Semi-Finals

Miller Beats Millar

Moore Beats Morrison

Finals

Moore Beats Miller

Champion

Alan Moore

Excatly how I predict them....

 

[Entropy]

Excatly how I predict them....

What I get for not reading all the posts. At least we know we're in agreement .

 

[thee great one]

Winners Of The Swank Sixteen

Brian Michael Bendis vs Chris Claremont
Mark Millar vs Larry Hama
Frank Miller vs JMS
BKV vs Kurt Busiek
Ed Brubaker vs Grant Morrison
Neil Gailman vs Greg Rucka
Alan Moore vs Mark Waid
Joss Whedon vs Garth Ennis

The Next Round...
The Excelsior Eight

Brian Micheal Bendis vs Mark Millar (Scribes Finals)
Frank Miller vs BKV (Scripters Finals)
Grant Morrison vs Neil Gailman (Dramalists Finals)
Alan Moore vs Joss Whedon (Wordsmiths Finals)

 

[Ice]

Mark Millar
BKV
Neil Gailman
Garth Ennis

 

[thee great one]

My votes...

Millar (He's my favorite writers)
BKV (I love his run on UXM)
Gailman (His 1602 is one of ny favorite stories)
Moore (Never read any of his work but his Twilght Of The Heros was amazing)

 

[Bass]

TGO - you should pick up something by Moore. There's lots of good comics by him. If you want a recommendation or something, I'll help you out.

Also, I voted for Millar, Miller, Morrison, and Moore.

Now that is the House of M.

 

[ProjectX2]

Mark Millar
BKV
Neil Gailman
Alan Moore

 

[moonmaster]

Millar (Duh)
Miller (One of my favorites)
Morrison (This one really sucked. I love them both. But I chose Morrison)
Moore (Duh 2: The Duhening)

 

[Entropy]

Voting "M's" down the line. I still think Moore's gonna come out the champion here.

 

[ProjectX2]

Voting "M's" down the line. I still think Moore's gonna come out the champion here.

I know Moore will win, but I want Millar to, so it shows how his comics have gone from good to great.

 

[Nurhachi]

Nooooooooooo Busieks out :cry:

Brian Micheal Bendis
BKV
Grant Morrison
Joss Whedon

 

[Lithium]

Bendis
BKV
Morrison
Whedon

 

[thee great one]

Here are the results of The Excelsior Eight

Brian Micheal Bendis vs Mark Millar (Scribes Finals)
Frank Miller vs BKV (Scripters Finals)
Grant Morrison vs Neil Gailman (Dramalists Finals)
Alan Moore vs Joss Whedon (Wordsmiths Finals)


and the Phenom Four

Brian Micheal Bendis vs Frank Miller
Neil Gailman vs. Alan Moore

 

[thee great one]

Miller and Gailman for me.

 

[Ice]

Bendis and Gailman.

 

[moonmaster]

Bendis beat Millar? That bald *****.

Miller and Moore.

(SCREW BENDIS!)

 

[Entropy]

How the hell did Gaiman beat Morrison?

Moore and Miller for me as well.