Army of Darkness contradicts Evil Dead 2's ending, as does Friday the 13th: Part III.
The difference is Army of Darkness is a sequel to Evil Dead 2. This Amityville movie isn't intended to be in the same continuity.
Amityville has also done time travel before, so it could just be a case of alternate timelines
I feel like that film's time travel was supposed to be self-contained.
I feel as though small snippets of murders from the first film being retconned out in favour of a full movie about them would be fine, and there's no other reason to just accept that it's not canon - like Leatherface (unless that was declared canon, though before this it was still added to the timeline, so the point still stands).
Quotes regardless the 2022 Texas Chainsaw Massacre film imply that every previous film can count as canon to it.
A few comics (such as AvFvJ: TNW) have just been BS-ed in, and things such as Freddy's Nightmares aren't even canon to their respective movies, so I don't see why any non-contradictory Amityville movies shouldn't be added in (though it would make it quite messy)
That comic is mainly just unintentional continuity errors. There's not really any substantial reason why Freddy's Nightmares can't be canon. If anything, Robert Englund's Freddy Krueger portrayal makes it more canon than other spin-off media.
Grandma Sawyer's corpse appears in The Howling, which was done by the same art director as TCM. A coven of werewolves is also mentioned in Child's Play: The Series #2. There's also a newspaper referencing Piranha, another John Dante film, and in Piranha 3D, Matt Hooper from Jaws appears. (This is a lot, and I get the Howling references are a bit scarce, but I just love the idea of Jaws being a part of this for some reason)
Yeah, I know about these references to The Howling, but I don't know the Piranha reference. I dismissed The Howling because they're not very valid connections.
Also, just asking for confirmation about some of the previous things I've mentioned, since after IT 1990 I haven't had any definitive answers, other than Dagon, which (as far as I'm aware) hasn't been added yet, and the errors haven't been fixed. Not sure if it's edited on a schedule or if it's whenever you get the chance, so confirmation about this would be appreciated (I get somewhat stressed when posts from days ago aren't acknowledged but more recent ones do, or answers that aren't definitive, so that I know for future queries)
I barely update this timeline much anymore. It's not necessarily abandoned, I just don't have the motivation for it. I should add in Dagon though, you're right.
If Creepshow does get added, would the Lost Boys easter egg be a viable connection? I know the Creephow segment with the missing person poster on the milk carton is set in 1978, but I don't know enough about The Lost Boys to know whether Laddie (the person on the milk carton) would be missing or not at this time
I don't even know about a connection with The Lost Boys, but that's very interesting. Creepshow is very confusing for continuity though, I personally prefer that be in its own plane. The TV show, I think, had a few things that might be alternate timelines and such, but also references other episodes and shorts. A big mess.
@Pro Bot just wondering when these will be followed up on?
Saw is a nightmare because this site is a bit buggy and forces me to write out the whole thing again, because if I just change the colour it glitches itself back into what it was. Definitely should fix that though.