Yeah but if the Red Dead games went out of their way not to reference the fictional GTA cities and only the real life ones, it might mean they don't really consider it the same universe.There's songs and the radio that mentions real locations. I never saw an issue with both the real and parody locations being on the same planet.
If Someone doesn't reference an event doesn't make It not Canon.Yeah but if the Red Dead games went out of their way not to reference the fictional GTA cities and only the real life ones, it might mean they don't really consider it the same universe.
It shows the intent really. Otherwise, they would show concrete connections to the series like inbetween Manhunt and 3D GTA.If Someone doesn't reference an event doesn't make It not Canon.
I'll make a simple and pratical example.... "I'm sitting at my desk" with that you know an event that happened in our universe, but if I didn't tell you you would be unaware. Don't knowing it or avoid to mention it, prevent it from happening? Nope.It shows the intent really. Otherwise, they would show concrete connections to the series like inbetween Manhunt and 3D GTA.
oh I'm sorry, I missunderstood, my fault!I meant the days the cases take place on
HD Universe.Wait Red Dead is part of the 3D Universe? I thought it was part of the HD universe because of the GTA Online family thing? Or is it just part of both universes?
That would only apply if Rockstar came out and said that Red Dead is the same universe as GTA, then it would not be a requirement for the games to acknowledge each other, but since Rockstar never made such a statement to my knowledge, all we can go off on are tenious connections, so such acknowledgements are important.I'll make a simple and pratical example.... "I'm sitting at my desk" with that you know an event that happened in our universe, but if I didn't tell you you would be unaware. Don't knowing it or avoid to mention it, prevent it from happening? Nope.
That's why I also find this argument as just an excuse to leave out certain media just cos of peoople's judgement.
Anyways LA Noire and Red Dead are here to stay.
Hes not gonna remove it. He already has Mafia which has 0 connections to anything. Why would Red Dead be removed just for more tenuous connections?That would only apply if Rockstar came out and said that Red Dead is the same universe as GTA, then it would not be a requirement for the games to acknowledge each other, but since Rockstar never made such a statement to my knowledge, all we can go off on are tenious connections, so such acknowledgements are important.
I remember reading a while back that there's a song in the game that references New Bordeaux from Mafia 3Hes not gonna remove it. He already has Mafia which has 0 connections to anything. Why would Red Dead be removed just for more tenuous connections?
In what game?I remember reading a while back that there's a song in the game that references New Bordeaux from Mafia 3
RDR2In what game?
Yeah I wasn't expecting him to change it. I posted more for discussion's sake.Hes not gonna remove it. He already has Mafia which has 0 connections to anything. Why would Red Dead be removed just for more tenuous connections?