I've gone and edited my comments I could find where I mention anything spoilery today so hopefully I don't fuck it for anyone else who hasn't seen it. Again I'm really sorry I spoiled that for you, I've always been forgetful with that kinda stuff, that's not cool.
Sorry I dropped the ball at the last second there. Well done avoiding spoilers tho. I'll be more careful going forward
Well, I found it pretty hard to step away from something I've been a part of for almost 10 years, started by someone i truly admire. But with the weird dictatorship that happened with this timeline when it's always been a collaborative effort long before you were here, I guess you made it a little easier.
I'll just say this: I think we can still get along as long as we realize that this timeline will likely fluctuate the longer the MCU goes on; so in reality, none of us are right until Marvel has this fully mapped out. That recent timeline book made that very clear with Phases 1-4.
see i feel like we should just ignore the 16 age for kamala in the marvels and say dec 2026/early 2027, again really depending on how long we think
I don't see how following a book released by Marvel Studios is a "dictatorship". The reason it's been as much of a collaborative effort before is because we didn't have Marvel's official take and just because we do now, doesn't mean there still can't be discussions. The thing is the book mostly lined up with here anyway.
I notice you replied only to the part where I told you to step away if you wanted to make vauge comments and not the part right before it where I said "If you want to contribute discussion about the timeline here and talk about why you think the placement should be different then please do so, make your points and we can discuss." Idk what you mean by "before you", I don't own this timeline, I'm just the third editor, I just write what's discussed down. DIrishB always ran this place off votes and This. Still. Stands. If you want to discuss then discuss. I get you don't like the timeline book, the Disney+ timeline or taking what Disney says as evidence for placements, but not everyone shares you're views.
Cassie has to be 18 during the events of the film, she was detained and held with other imates by the police, if she wasn't she would've been brought home. Geekritique went into it better than me but TLDR there is evidence in film of her being 18
I do want to make it clear, this is always how this timeline will function. After a couple of days of discussion where everyone can make points, if a clear answer doesn't show a vote will be taken as usual. Nothing has changed there
It absolutely is not based on votes. You made a big post saying "sorry if you don't like it, but we're basing everything on the book, the book is God now and that's just the way it's going to be." There was no discussion. It was a decision you made. Granted, a vote may have gone that way anyway, but there was no vote, there was no discussion. It was very much "my way or the highway". And then you moved all the dates to match the book. I have not seen one vote since the book came out.
I'll step in his defense and note that I actually did most of the changes myself and gave the file to Starvel, he mostly made smaller adjustments. And most of the discussion seemed to be generally in favor of most of the changes.
Okay fine there wasn't an offical vote but like I said after discussion I thought the answer was clear and as I stated "After a couple of days of discussion where everyone can make points, if a clear answer doesn't show a vote will be taken as usual." there was some worry about retconning or removing old canon material like the comics which I addressed by saying none would be removed and the new information would be combined with the old. People agreed rearranging the pages was a good idea, I believe it was Selfishmisery who made that comment, and that post was liked, no counterargument was made so I went with it with that as a sign the changes could be made with a GREAT deal of assistance from Lebnyx.
Lol yeah I didn't want to throw you under the bus but like I stated back when the changes were put into the first post Lebnyx did the majority of the work, I did minor fixes and mostly handled the Fury's Big Week and Civil War-Black Panther areas which he still provided assistance on. Lebnyx really stepped up when he didn't have to for this group and saved me just so many days of work
