Publius
Well-Known Member
"Tobe": The opening sequence is the conversation between Jody and Toby seen in Phantasm. After failing to leave town twice and losing time both times, Tobe comes upon Reggie's overturned ice-cream truck, and he is run off the road avoiding Jody's Plymouth 'Cuda and sees the passing funeral coach from Tommy's funeral with Mike in the back. He arrives at Morningside Mortuary and Cemetery in time to see the funeral coach explode, and he hears a shotgun blast inside. He bumps into Reggie immediately after Reggie "closed his gate."
Notes:
Jody's service overseas is strange. The Novel makes clear that Jody had "had been gone for two years" immediately after "the night he graduated from high school" (23), and that he "worked as a roadie, traveling with the big rock groups" and that George Norby, his family bank's manager, "worked miracles finding Jody and getting him back in time for the funeral (24). Since Phantasm establishes that Jody Pearson Sr. and Ann Pearson died in 1977, that means that Jody left in June or July 1975, just in time for the Rolling Stones' Tour of the Americas 75 (June 1 – August 8, 1975). Phantasm establishes that Mike is thirteen in 1979, and The Novel that Jody is "nine years older" (84), so Jody was born in 1957 and is old enough for Selective Service the same year he graduated high school, 1975. He must have been drafted between August 1975 and Norby managing to find him after his parents' deaths in 1977. But that doesn't work: the Paris Peace Accords were settled in January 1973, and with them, the draft was discontinued.
"The Rocky Road": Coscarelli says in his "Introduction to "The Rocky Road"" that "In writing The Rocky Road, I have attempted to depict the events in this character's life, which directly precede Phantasm III." Rocky specifically says "it's 1993" on the phone with her aunt. Loy forced Rocky's father, Rodney, out of his business "well over a year ago." Rocky and Tanesha leave the empty town of Chunchula to head to Holtsville, Oregon, where Tanesha hasn't been able to reach her family "for the past month."
Coscarelli appears to have forgotten his timeline quite thoroughly. Phantasm III was released in 1994, but it was not set in 1994. Phantasm is set in the summer "two years" after 1977 (i.e., 1979), Phantasm II has Mike say he was at Morningside Psychiatric Clinic for "seven years" (i.e., 1986), and Phantasm III has Reggie say he has been restoring the Hemi 'cuda for "two years" while Mike was hospitalized (i.e., 1988) and tells Mike "your brother's been dead for ten years." The final sequence of "A Winged Sphere for a Mint Green Mummy" is set in 1978, with Jody already dead.
Rocky's crypto-girlfriend Althea is explicitly said to have been killed by an Iraqi Scud when she was deployed to Saudi Arabia in support of Operation Desert Storm (January-February 1991) and Rocky tells her aunt the year is 1993. There's not any wiggle room there. At the same time, the story absolutely cannot be set in the 1990s. In Phantasm III, Rocky and Tanesha are clearly wearing the old olive-green Utility Uniform (OG-107s) discontinued in favor of the camouflage Battle Dress Uniform (BDUs) in 1989.
Of course, just because something didn't happen, that doesn't mean it didn't happen. Jody was emphatically dead by 1979, and Reggie both closed a dimensional fork and was killed that summer—but Tobe saw Jody at Tommy's funeral and at Morningside, and Reggie didn't believe he'd done either of those things (despite remembering the former in Phantasm III). At least one version of Reggie took Mike to the Vietnam Veterans Memorial in 1987, apparently, when Mike was comatose in a hospital.
Maybe one version of Rocky and Tanesha were Gulf War era veterans and went to Holtsville in 1993 instead of 1988? Maybe this version of the women—who have not encountered anything overtly preter- or supernatural—is from the alternate timeline seen in Phantasm: RaVager? Or a timeline inhabited by a version of Reggie agreeing not to pursue The Tall Man in RaVager, in which it has more time to play its game unharried by the Ice Cream Man?
Notes:
- Coscarelli acknowledges that the character was named Toby in Phantasm, but that he has renamed him Tobe in honor of Tobe Hooper. Presumably he went by "Toby" before he left home, and adopted the "Tobe" later, with his hometown friends not quite adjusting to the change. Similarly, Kate Coscarelli identifies him as a medical student in The Novel, but he works at a financial services firm in Portland here. Perhaps he was originally pre-medicine but eventually switched to finance, and his hometown friends either don't know or don't' remember.
- Tobe explicitly identifies the house seen in Phantasm as "the Pearson brothers' two-story home" in the neighborhood of "Morningside Heights" and the town as "Morningside proper," in "the Township of Morningside."
- Tobe is "headed back to Portland today" by way of Highway 59. Along with Holtsville being explicitly located in Oregon in "He Was Home Alone," this more or less confirms that Phantasm is set in Oregon.
- Tobe earned a scholarship at OSU and spent four years in Corvallis, avoiding the draft. Jody "had not been so fortunate and served a tour of duty in the conflict overseas."
- Tobe witnesses the events at Morningside and flees back to Portland, confirming that they did happen in some way, despite very much not having happened (as seen at the end of Phantasm and the beginning of Phantasm II), unless they did (as Reggie remembers something that didn't happen in Phantasm III). So, there's that.
Jody's service overseas is strange. The Novel makes clear that Jody had "had been gone for two years" immediately after "the night he graduated from high school" (23), and that he "worked as a roadie, traveling with the big rock groups" and that George Norby, his family bank's manager, "worked miracles finding Jody and getting him back in time for the funeral (24). Since Phantasm establishes that Jody Pearson Sr. and Ann Pearson died in 1977, that means that Jody left in June or July 1975, just in time for the Rolling Stones' Tour of the Americas 75 (June 1 – August 8, 1975). Phantasm establishes that Mike is thirteen in 1979, and The Novel that Jody is "nine years older" (84), so Jody was born in 1957 and is old enough for Selective Service the same year he graduated high school, 1975. He must have been drafted between August 1975 and Norby managing to find him after his parents' deaths in 1977. But that doesn't work: the Paris Peace Accords were settled in January 1973, and with them, the draft was discontinued.
"The Rocky Road": Coscarelli says in his "Introduction to "The Rocky Road"" that "In writing The Rocky Road, I have attempted to depict the events in this character's life, which directly precede Phantasm III." Rocky specifically says "it's 1993" on the phone with her aunt. Loy forced Rocky's father, Rodney, out of his business "well over a year ago." Rocky and Tanesha leave the empty town of Chunchula to head to Holtsville, Oregon, where Tanesha hasn't been able to reach her family "for the past month."
- Rocky lived in Le Moyne but spent her childhood at her father Rodney's car shop, Eugene's Auto, in the township of Creola, outside Mobile. They had moved to a different neighborhood in Oakdale after three Klansmen murdered a man in their neighborhood in 1981.
- She enlisted in the Army and drove supply trucks in "the Second Armored Division Forward, Third Brigade Mobile" in Germany. The 3rd Brigade (Forward), 2nd Armored Division, operated as 2nd Armored Division (Forward) and was stationed at Garlstedt; it was reorganized as 2nd Armored Division in September 1991, and was inactivated in 1992. As a motor vehicle operator, Rocky may have been assigned to the 498th Support Battalion (Forward).
- Rocky hid her Lesbian relationship with fellow motor vehicle operator Althea because "the law of the land was "Don't' ask, don't tell."" Their relationship was interrupted by Al's deployment to Saudi Arabia for Operation Desert Storm, where she was killed by a Scud strike on a barracks in Al Khobar. The "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" (DADT) policy was signed into law as Public Law 103-160 in November 1993, and implemented effective February 28, 1994.
- Rocky's Auntie Velinda calls her "Quonesha." With her name tape "VERAY" being visible in the hotel scene in Phantasm III, we now know her full name is Quonesha Veray.
- Rocky meets Tanesha in a USO lounge. Tanesha "mustered out yesterday" and is headed to her hometown of Holtsville, Oregon.
- Chunchula, "a half-hour drive north from Mobile," has been emptied.
Coscarelli appears to have forgotten his timeline quite thoroughly. Phantasm III was released in 1994, but it was not set in 1994. Phantasm is set in the summer "two years" after 1977 (i.e., 1979), Phantasm II has Mike say he was at Morningside Psychiatric Clinic for "seven years" (i.e., 1986), and Phantasm III has Reggie say he has been restoring the Hemi 'cuda for "two years" while Mike was hospitalized (i.e., 1988) and tells Mike "your brother's been dead for ten years." The final sequence of "A Winged Sphere for a Mint Green Mummy" is set in 1978, with Jody already dead.
Rocky's crypto-girlfriend Althea is explicitly said to have been killed by an Iraqi Scud when she was deployed to Saudi Arabia in support of Operation Desert Storm (January-February 1991) and Rocky tells her aunt the year is 1993. There's not any wiggle room there. At the same time, the story absolutely cannot be set in the 1990s. In Phantasm III, Rocky and Tanesha are clearly wearing the old olive-green Utility Uniform (OG-107s) discontinued in favor of the camouflage Battle Dress Uniform (BDUs) in 1989.
Of course, just because something didn't happen, that doesn't mean it didn't happen. Jody was emphatically dead by 1979, and Reggie both closed a dimensional fork and was killed that summer—but Tobe saw Jody at Tommy's funeral and at Morningside, and Reggie didn't believe he'd done either of those things (despite remembering the former in Phantasm III). At least one version of Reggie took Mike to the Vietnam Veterans Memorial in 1987, apparently, when Mike was comatose in a hospital.
Maybe one version of Rocky and Tanesha were Gulf War era veterans and went to Holtsville in 1993 instead of 1988? Maybe this version of the women—who have not encountered anything overtly preter- or supernatural—is from the alternate timeline seen in Phantasm: RaVager? Or a timeline inhabited by a version of Reggie agreeing not to pursue The Tall Man in RaVager, in which it has more time to play its game unharried by the Ice Cream Man?
Last edited:
