Timeline Hub

[Rojinn]

Oh, I'm sorry, misremembered

Well it can't be Stargirl's Earth-2 because of the newspaper mentioning Top Trio defeating Ultra-Humanite, who had been in hiding for 70+ years and the same year (2021) in Stargirl.

That's what they actually said for clarification, sorry again

 

[Rojinn]

At the risk of spoiling the fun, no, the Batman Epic Crime Saga isn't set on Stargirl's Earth-2, and Peacemaker isn't really visting it either.

Fair, I don't think that little timeline was meant as more than a just for fun "what if we take all Live-Action Earth-2s as one" ^^

 

[Zeitschiene]

At the risk of spoiling the fun, no, the Batman Epic Crime Saga isn't set on Stargirl's Earth-2, and Peacemaker isn't really visting it either.

Spoiled the fun? Yes, but that's alright

 

[Zeitschiene]

And there is some suspicion already about Peacemaker's "Earth-2" not really being that. More like Earth-10/X

What di you mean?

 

[Zeitschiene]

One would think in the live-action multiverse The Batman Epic Crime Saga is "Earth-46".

Well, but it isn't

 

[selfishmisery]

Well, but it isn't

You're right, but it's not Earth-2 either.

 

[Pro Bot]

The Batman could be set on Earth-2 with Stargirl, but the designation hasn't really been verified in-canon. Same with Peacemaker S2.

I consider Stargirl to be the legitimate Earth-2 at the moment.

 

[Rojinn]

Quick question about George Reeves' Superman. What is canon to his universe?

Superman and the Mole Men
Stamp Day for Superman
Adventures of Superman S1-6
The Flash (DCEU Film)

What about his cameo as Superman in I Love Lucy (he's actually a dick in that one)? Apparently, he also appeared on Funny Boners as Superman. And the actress who portrayed Lois Lane in Seasons 2-6 of Adventures of Superman is the same Lois Lane actress from the two Kirk Alyn Superman serials. So, are they the same Superman, just with a different actor?

 

[Pro Bot]

I Love Lucy's Superman is actually George Reeves dressed up as Superman. They did it in a way where children watching would see Superman and adults would see George... if I recall correctly.

 

[Rojinn]

I Love Lucy's Superman is actually George Reeves dressed up as Superman. They did it in a way where children watching would see Superman and adults would see George... if I recall correctly.

Oh, that's interesting, thanks

 

[TotallyNotAPigeon]

Not seen either of them so I don't know the extent of their differences, but Reeves' mother was Sarah Kent and Alyn's was Martha

Adventures of Superman also had Kellogg's commercials which could be in-universe made by the Daily Planet (since they also star Perry and Jimmy), but there'd have to be a reason why they say "Clark Kent, the star of Superman", and why they act like he has x-ray vision. Maybe their own tv series where he's secretly portraying himself? Which could also mean the actor playing Superman in I Love Lucy is Clark Kent, not George Reeves

 

[barryh]

They did it in a way where children watching would see Superman and adults would see George... if I recall correctly.

There's a moment he casually pushes a piano out of the way to hop out a window, shocking other characters, but it's not necessarily a superhuman feat. You can read it either way.

 

[Rojinn]

Oh, is The Adventures of Superboy Pilot considered to be the same universe?

 

[Rojinn]

Oh, is The Adventures of Superboy Pilot considered to be the same universe?

Same problem with Clark's earth parents' names. In Adventures of Superman they are named Ebben and Sarah Kent, while they have their classic names in the Superboy Pilot

 

[Frizzy]

I don't know where else to put this so I'll do it here, and I'm sure a lot of people have already seen it (if you haven't and don't like brutality then don't watch). Thoughts?

 

[Pro Bot]

this guy puts Holy Terror too.

I forgot to mention, Holy Terror isn't canon. The Fixer replaced Batman in the story which means that there's zero links to Earth-31.