Which was better? Superman Returns vs. Batman Begins

Which DC flick was better?

  • Superman Returns

    Votes: 5 23.8%
  • Batman Begins

    Votes: 16 76.2%

  • Total voters
    21
  • Poll closed .

MaxwellSmart

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 21, 2004
Messages
3,335
Location
SoCal
I personally didn't like Batman Begins that much and really enjoyed Superman Returns, so it's a no brainer for me. I started this thread because I got into an arguement with my brother-in-law yesterday over which was better, and he was shocked I could consider Superman Returns better. He was half a sleep through the movie and he's always grouchy when he's sleepy, so I think he opinion is skewed.

Anyway, what do you guys think?
 

Dr.Strangefate

He Sees You When You're Sleeping. He Knows When Yo
Joined
Oct 24, 2004
Messages
10,075
Location
New York, NY
I enjoyed Superman Returns very much, very very much, but Batman Begins was nearly perfect in my opinion...

I say Batman Begins, if only for the Supporting Cast. Oldman as Gordon. Caine as Alfred. Freeman as Lucius Fox. And Liam Neeson as Ra's Al Ghul (well, Ducard, who is later revealed to be Ra's Al Ghul). Also, The Scarecrow was wonderfully done.

Superman had a great supporting cast, but I was expecting that. The biggest surprise was how likable Jimmy Olsen turned out to be (bowtie and all).

Lois Lane beats Rachel Dawes

But Batman beats Superman. Hands down.
 

MaxwellSmart

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 21, 2004
Messages
3,335
Location
SoCal
I have to admit my big peeve with Batman was the end game of the... who were the bad guys?... anyway. I also hated the "super weapon" they planned to use, but this is all the science geek in me. To be fair, the throwing of Kryponite Island into space bugged the crap out of me.

The entire cast gave great performances with the note able exception of Katie Holmes. It just needed better writers.

I also felt the characterization was a little better done in Superman than Batman, but both were excellent.


My One Thousandth Post!!! I knew I get here eventually.
 
Last edited:

Friday

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2004
Messages
8,903
Location
Washington, PA
...Superman. Batman Begins was good, nay great, but Superman was friggin perfect. I watched the first two the day before and it was so god damned spot on... I was grinning like an idiot through the whole thing.
 

MaxwellSmart

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 21, 2004
Messages
3,335
Location
SoCal
Thank you, Baxter, I thought I was surrounded by crazies around here. Or would that have meant I was the crazy person? No, Superman was better.
 
Last edited:

Victor Von Doom

Fist of teh Internets.
Joined
Oct 19, 2005
Messages
16,964
Location
On The Edge
MaxwellSmart said:
Thank you, Baxter, I thought I was surrounded by crazies around here. Or would that have meant I was the crazy person? No, Superman was better.

Nay. The 2 of you are not alone. You have Doom's support in the fight.

Seriously. While Batman Begins was just a great film...not just comic book movie...but actual film, Superman Returns is just that much more greater.

Unfortunately this debate will be more in tune with who people think is better. Batman fans will side with Batman. Superman fans will stand along side Superman.

Superman is the better film.
 

E.Vi.L.

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2005
Messages
1,276
Location
Montréal
Victor Von Doom said:
Superman is the better film.

That's not the average opinions of a few hundred movie critics.

Currently, Superman Return ranks at 76% on Rotten Tomatoes while Batman Begins stands at 83%.

That's not a crushing victory, but 7% is still subtsantial in a large sample group.

And beofre people get into it, I discount the opinion of one or two critics as easily as anyone else. But Rotten Tomatoes compile a lot of movie critics. 230 for BB and 158 so far for SR.

Of course, we are all entitled to our opinion. But BB has wooed a statistically significant higher percentage of its critics, most of whom have never read either comics. I say the edge goes to BB.
 
Last edited:

thee great one

Master of TOG-fu.
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Messages
15,570
Location
Mormon Land.
The plot of Batman was much better and had a better twist.

The humor and characters were much better.

Batman was just the better film.
 

Dr.Strangefate

He Sees You When You're Sleeping. He Knows When Yo
Joined
Oct 24, 2004
Messages
10,075
Location
New York, NY
I tend to like Darker stuff, I think most moviegoers do... So I don't think Superman has much of a chance of outranking Batman...
 

ProjectX2

Don't expect me to take you with me when I go to s
Joined
Sep 15, 2004
Messages
25,007
I felt Batman Begins was pretty much perfect. Superman was great, but it felt as if something was missing.

Plus, I like Batman more. :)
 

Sacred&Profane

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 8, 2006
Messages
998
Location
Indiana
Batman Begins was far better for me...and I don't really read DC comics, and don't have much expierence with either character past their wiki articles/animated shows/movies.

I just didn't like Superman all that much:(
 

Iceshadow

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 10, 2005
Messages
12,124
Location
Houston,Texas
I preferred Batman, mostly because I liked Scarecrow and Ras Al Ghul more than Luthor (not to say that I didn't like Lex).
 

ProjectX2

Don't expect me to take you with me when I go to s
Joined
Sep 15, 2004
Messages
25,007
Bump.

So now that both movies are on DVDs, have you opinions changed?

Upon rewatching both, I still think Batman Begins was better. Batman is my favourite comic character of all time, and it was great to finally see an excellent movie with him in it.

I've never really loved Superman, I just thought he was alright, but Superman Returns was still good.

There is no debate that these two are probably the greatest superhero movies ever.
 

Victor Von Doom

Fist of teh Internets.
Joined
Oct 19, 2005
Messages
16,964
Location
On The Edge
I'm still all about the Superman.

While Batman was a great movie---one of the biggets detractors of the movie (for me anyways) was that the cinematography was really subpar for an action film. With the exception of the training fights between Bruce/Ras on the ice----you could never tell what was going in a fight. The camera was jumpy...the cuts were to quick. It just really bugged me.

Singer had the picture just perfect. You could always see what was going on. He had just the right angles. The score was better.



To me---Supes was just the better film. Comparing them is like comparing between Bendis and Brubaker on DD. Both are superb....but you gotta like one just a bit more than the other.
 

Hibiki

Really is pretentious, no matter what she says. Do
Joined
May 17, 2006
Messages
5,972
Location
Anytime USA all the way
I really dislike Superman. really DC but i like 52 and i like Batman. Now I like Ralph Dibny. That's a pretty good analogy on the ben/bru thing. Still, I don't know if i can bring myself to watch Superman. MY bf just bought Red Son and was told that it was really good. It was by Millar so of course. So if I can bring myself to read that, then I guess watching the movie is possible.
 

Random

Didn't **** any of those *****es
Joined
Jun 16, 2005
Messages
13,680
Location
Philadelphia, PA
With the exception of the training fights between Bruce/Ras on the ice----you could never tell what was going in a fight. The camera was jumpy...the cuts were to quick. It just really bugged me.

They did that on purpose, they were showing the fight from the perspective of the bad guys, emphazing the fear Batman projects on them. But I understand why you didnt like it
 

Latest posts

Top