Pro Bot
Well-Known Member
Non-canon X-Men tie-ins timeline when? I could do it.
You already have:Non-canon X-Men tie-ins timeline when? I could do it.
Comic Book Adaptation Timeline
1944
????
X-Men Movie Adaptation #1 (pg. 1)
X-Men: The Movie Prequel: Magneto #1 (pg. 1-5)
1979
March
X-Men Movie Adaptation #1 (pg. 17-18)
1988
????
X-Men Movie Adaptation #1 (pg. 1-2)
1992
????
X-Men: The Movie Prequel: Magneto #1 (pg. 14-23)
1994
????
X-Men: The Movie Prequel: Magneto #1 (pg. 24-43)
1999
????
X-Men Movie Adaptation #1 (pg. 2)
2000
????
X-Men: The Movie Prequel: Magneto #1 (pg. 6-10)
X-Men: The Movie Prequel: Rogue #1 (pg. 6-7)
X-Men: The Movie Prequel: Rogue #1 (pg. 1-6, 8-19)
X-Men: The Movie Prequel: Magneto #1 (pg. 11-13, 44-46)
X-Men: The Movie Prequel: Rogue #1 (pg. 20-46)
X-Men: The Movie Prequel: Wolverine #1 (pg. 1-46)
X-Men Movie Adaptation #1 (pg. 3-5)
X-Men: The Movie Prequel: Wolverine #1 (pg. 46-47)
X-Men: The Movie Prequel: Rogue #1 (pg. 47)
X-Men Movie Adaptation #1 (pg. 6-47)
2006
????
X-Men: The Movie Special #1, "Call to Arms"
Maybe it's small Wolverine's universe. (I'm kidding, he was definitely a bit smaller than 5.3 in D&W, but... just a fun thought.)
According to what exactly?Also New Mutants literally takes place within a day or so after the woman who adopts X-23 snuck in and took footage of the experiments, the same footage is reused from Logan.
Does it even though? All it shows is charles and erik telling logan theres a bigger threat coming. They could've easily just dealt with that off-screen between movies without time travel.What about The Wolverine's mid-credits scene that leads into DOFP?
Regardless of whether things seem to not align (even though you're still making up ways to explain other plotholes if it helps your case) the intention by the creators of the FoX-Men meant for Logan to be post-DoFP, no matter how inconsistent it may be. That'd be like saying Doctor Who season 1 isn't canon because it implies Susan came up with the name Tardis, or that Army of Darkness isn't canon because it retcons Evil Dead 2 - the Rule of God always takes precedence (unless numerous people working on something disagree, since Rule of God wouldn't be able to apply in the first place)Does it even though? All it shows is charles and erik telling logan theres a bigger threat coming. They could've easily just dealt with that off-screen between movies without time travel.
Also, it shows an advert on tv for trask industries' robotic limbs, as if they hadn't went public yet about their true intentions. Yet in 25 moments we learn that by 2015 the war between mutants and sentinels had already well and truly begun. So none of it really makes sense unless you just say it's 2 separate timelines. Logan is a direct sequel to the original timeline movies and dofp is a direct sequel to First Class, with nothing but 25 moments and maybe some similar events to the original timeline movies in between.
Difference being Magneto is locked up in that timeline and the events of the first two films played out mostly similar ways.You already have:
The film? New Mutants?According to what exactly?
I have a lot of issues with that. For one, Dani was meant to be seeing a vision of where they would be heading afterwards, why would they be headed to the Transigen research facility? That place was for the x-23 and 24 project. Also I don't see how Dr. Reyes would've been able to see that footage, it was filmed in secret by nurse Gabrielle on her phone. If Dr. Reyes somehow got hold of that footage then surely she would've had nurse Gabrielle fired.The film? New Mutants?
When one of them is peering into the doctor lady's mind (I forget names, I don't forget events) you see the same footage from Logan, of the kids walking down the hospital halls to their doom, you can assume that she saw and whatever the former employee saw were moments apart from each other.
LITERALLY a "small world" coincidence lol.
Naw. The Logan connection was definitely intentional.I have a lot of issues with that. For one, Dani was meant to be seeing a vision of where they would be heading afterwards, why would they be headed to the Transigen research facility? That place was for the x-23 and 24 project. Also I don't see how Dr. Reyes would've been able to see that footage, it was filmed in secret by nurse Gabrielle on her phone. If Dr. Reyes somehow got hold of that footage then surely she would've had nurse Gabrielle fired.
Dr. Reyes had also seemingly been working at the New Mutants facility for at-least a few years, don't see why she would just take a quick trip down to Mexico. Then theres also the fact that all the new mutants would then have to be born after 2004.
The way I view it is the same way I view the fact that they showed 10005 wolverine flashbacks when probing 'worst Wolverine's' mind in dp&w. What we see on screen is just not what the actual characters were seeing. It was obviously just a cost saving measure to use the footage from Logan in NM and I don't think you should really pay much attention to it.
Also, very often are species declared extinct only for years later for them to pop up again and thus no longer extinct but still endangered.Naw. The Logan connection was definitely intentional.
In regards to the "No new mutants born after 2004", I mean, as an estimate yeah. There would be 1% of leftovers in the next generation; possibly why the New Mutants were so special to begin with.
I like to think of the franchise as 3 sagas,A couple years ago I was toying with the X-Men continuity and discovered that you can experience the saga in lots of different manners :
I skipped Wolverine Origins, Deadpool 1 & 2, Logan, Dark Phoenix, and New Mutants because they don't fit in.
- X-Men
- X-Men United
- X-Men : Last Stand
- X-Men : First Class
- The Wolverine
- X-Men : Days of Future Past
- X-Men : Apocalypse (sh*t movie, but great conclusion for the saga)
X-Men '97 gave me the need to get another crack at the franchise but I didn't have a lot of time, so I came up with what I consider probably the best way for non-Marvel fans to have a shot at the X-Men saga :
This makes a perfect trilogy, with little to no inconsistencies, there are only some nods to the first X-Men film and some references to the Weapon X program which can be found in the second installment. What's left is a great three-parter with the thematic of found-family as its core
- X-Men
- X-Men United
- Logan
(I'd say it fits into the Logan saga, but let's not start that debate again lol)Oh and then theres New Mutants which doesn't really fit into any of these
Yeah but in terms of like, character arcs and connected storylines between the movies its basically a stand alone(I'd say it fits into the Logan saga, but let's not start that debate again lol)
Finally finished it, lot of fun but I wouldn't say it fits into canon any more than the movie does. I mean, theres no way mystique could've been on Team X. Nightcrawler isn't even born yet. It also has a different Bolliver Trask, I know the last stand does too but they never give you his first name so its easy enough to assume he was just someone different. The DoFP bookends were cool but also kinda pointless and completely unrelated to the game idk. I wonder if there was ever any plans to have something like that in the movie. Theres a lot of points in the story where you would have absolutely no idea whats going on unless you had seen the movie. They kinda skip over some important parts of the plot. Enjoyable game thoughAnyone played the Origins Wolverine game? I think it's the best pre-Arkham superhero game, especially for a movie tie-in. I actually think it fits into canon much better than the film. I love the DoFP tease in the bookends too. Really cool stuff in there
X-Men: The Last Stand's "Trask", you mean.It also has a different Bolliver Trask.
@selfishmisery
Could these be added to the timeline since they are in-universe? (also they should be archived as there are no mirrors I could find and I wouldn't be surprised if these get deleted someday).
@selfishmisery
Could these be added to the timeline since they are in-universe? (also they should be archived as there are no mirrors I could find and I wouldn't be surprised if these get deleted someday).
Yeah, maybe it won't fit in a timeline. Albeit I still consider them canon (Emma Frost was retconned though).They're just little inner thought promo pieces, I don't see how or where you would put these in a timeline. I should add it to my list of tie in media though
These are the only three I could find.Was it just these 3 or where there any more?