Who has read this?
Thoughts?
Thoughts?
Morrison/Quitely: JLA: Earth 2
- Thread starter E
- Start date
thee great one
Master of TOG-fu.
I've been planning to get it. I read the sequel, which sucked balls.
ProjectX2
Don't expect me to take you with me when I go to s
I've heard it's overrated.
Friday
Well-Known Member
Great minds think alike, I just re-read this yesterday.
It was good, but not excellent. I enjoyed alot of the depth given to earth 1 (The anti-matter earth) thanks to Morrisons exploration of the flipped Gotham and journalistic changes. As usual I was Lukewarm to quietlys artwork (Everyone is so chunky) but didn't mind it atall by the end. And of course Luthor was a badass.
A good read, a must if you're reading Morrison's JLA.
It was good, but not excellent. I enjoyed alot of the depth given to earth 1 (The anti-matter earth) thanks to Morrisons exploration of the flipped Gotham and journalistic changes. As usual I was Lukewarm to quietlys artwork (Everyone is so chunky) but didn't mind it atall by the end. And of course Luthor was a badass.
A good read, a must if you're reading Morrison's JLA.
Bass
Nexus of the World
Yeah, it's quite good. Quitely's wonderful.
The main problem with the story is that you expect to see the CSA fight the JLA.
That never happens.
Aquaman and Martian Manhunter do take on the CSA, but Batman never takes on Owlman, and because of that, it's lacking.
It's good, but it's not the "event" it looks like.
The main problem with the story is that you expect to see the CSA fight the JLA.
That never happens.
Aquaman and Martian Manhunter do take on the CSA, but Batman never takes on Owlman, and because of that, it's lacking.
It's good, but it's not the "event" it looks like.
Bass said:
But the explanation why is pretty clever. I preferred it actually.
Patriot Mk2
The poster formerly known as Johnny Bravo
Never read this, but Busiek's follow-up CSA arc in JLA was absolute crap.
Patriot Mk2 said:
Busiek is no Morrison.
And it didn't really seem like the kind of story that needed to be followed up on...:?
Patriot Mk2
The poster formerly known as Johnny Bravo
UltimateE said:
The CSA were attacking the DCU heroes. Thats the gist of it.
Patriot Mk2 said:
Well then I believe you that it was crap, because one of the most interesting points about Earth 2 was that the CSA *couldn't* fight the JLA (or anyone else).
thee great one
Master of TOG-fu.
UltimateE said:
He changed that. It was bad. Beyond bad.
thee great one
Master of TOG-fu.
I got this today. It was fantastic. Best JLA story by far.
A-
A-
Ultimates
Well-Known Member
Then u def. havent read Tower Of Babel, which was DEF. the best JLA story 
Dr.Strangefate
He Sees You When You're Sleeping. He Knows When Yo
best JLA story was Rock of Ages, but I love Earth 2...
Owlman has intrigued me for such a long time...
He is the son of Thomas and Martha from a world where his brother bruce and his mother were gunned down by one of the corrupt cops in his father's force... Thomas Jr. went crazy for a while, and disapeared, probably to become a drunk. Then one day he figures out he wants to fight his father's justice, but he's too lazy, so he uses drugs and brain enhancers and steriods and all that stuff to become stronger and faster than the cops.
Then he took over the Gotham Underworld.
The best part of the Busiek arc was the hint at Robin. Owlman kills Jack Drake for not paying debt, and takes his son as debt.
Owlman owns a kid. Does that not terrify you?
Owlman is also just as smart as Batman... he just got to that point in the least respectable way.
The other heroes intrigue me too...
Ultraman was an ******* military dumb**** who became an astronaut and nearly died in an explosion. He was put back together by anti-kryptonians and Anti-Kryptonite is the thing that keeps him strong and alive.
I get the idea that Superwoman was an amazon who killed Clark Kent's wife and took her place. She is Lois Lane.
Johnny Quick created an opiate-like serum from the blood of the first Johnny Quick, from which he gets his speed powers.
Power Ring has an intelligent power ring that seems to be run by fear, possibly the anti-matter universe's parallax... Under the guise of a Monk.
...
The only real hero of the world is Lex Luthor, but there are others who try, like (my personal favorite) The Quizmaster, the smartest Man Alive (think: the good guy Riddler).
Owlman has intrigued me for such a long time...
He is the son of Thomas and Martha from a world where his brother bruce and his mother were gunned down by one of the corrupt cops in his father's force... Thomas Jr. went crazy for a while, and disapeared, probably to become a drunk. Then one day he figures out he wants to fight his father's justice, but he's too lazy, so he uses drugs and brain enhancers and steriods and all that stuff to become stronger and faster than the cops.
Then he took over the Gotham Underworld.
The best part of the Busiek arc was the hint at Robin. Owlman kills Jack Drake for not paying debt, and takes his son as debt.
Owlman owns a kid. Does that not terrify you?
Owlman is also just as smart as Batman... he just got to that point in the least respectable way.
The other heroes intrigue me too...
Ultraman was an ******* military dumb**** who became an astronaut and nearly died in an explosion. He was put back together by anti-kryptonians and Anti-Kryptonite is the thing that keeps him strong and alive.
I get the idea that Superwoman was an amazon who killed Clark Kent's wife and took her place. She is Lois Lane.
Johnny Quick created an opiate-like serum from the blood of the first Johnny Quick, from which he gets his speed powers.
Power Ring has an intelligent power ring that seems to be run by fear, possibly the anti-matter universe's parallax... Under the guise of a Monk.
...
The only real hero of the world is Lex Luthor, but there are others who try, like (my personal favorite) The Quizmaster, the smartest Man Alive (think: the good guy Riddler).
Pandrio
Well-Known Member
Yeah, I liked it and am reading through Morrison's JLA.Baxter said:
I don't think I would go that far.Tog said:
I didn't really like Quitely's artwork (looking at it that is in the AS-S preview), until I actually read AS Superman, I don't know why, but it just seems to fit Morrison's writing.Bass said:
Bass
Nexus of the World
Morrison and Quitely work very well together. Much like Millar and Hitch or Azzarello and Risso, to use recent examples.
Pandrio
Well-Known Member
Yeah, I don't know what I would think of Quitely's art outside of a Morrison story.Bass said:
ProjectX2
Don't expect me to take you with me when I go to s
I read this last night. It was great.
I both love and hate Quitely's art. I respect in an iconic-like way, but hate the way it looks... :?
The story was fun. I loved how Aquaman and Martian Manhunter took on the CSA on their own. It showed how they can be the two most powerful members.
Great stuff.
I both love and hate Quitely's art. I respect in an iconic-like way, but hate the way it looks... :?
The story was fun. I loved how Aquaman and Martian Manhunter took on the CSA on their own. It showed how they can be the two most powerful members.
Great stuff.
Friday
Well-Known Member
I think Quietly has come a long way since Earth 2, especially in how he draws women. Just look at Cat Grant in E2 and tell me she doesn't look like a crack whore. Now look as All Star Superman. They women look like people instead of sticks with boobies.
