Powers

Grocer Man

Grocer Man

Well-Known Member
Since we've been so cruel to Bendis, I think it's only fair we talk about his original series.



I've only read the first arc, but I thought it was pretty good.
 
ourchair

ourchair

Well-Known Member
E said:
I only read the first ICON arc, and didn't care for it...
Click to expand...
The first ICON arc was only enjoyable if you read the entire Image run, 60% of which was complete drivel.

I have no idea why people think Powers is where Bendis is never crap. It's full of infantile conversational gags, annoying cop-out endings that keep detectives from detecting, loads of typographical errors.

Also, inserting 'Easter eggs' in the form of civilians and streets named after buddies and comic book creator names stopped being cute after the first arc. Now it's just detracting and annoying and even if you were a person who wouldn't recognize those names, it doesn't add anything to the book so why not just attempt to create a real sense of urban space to this unnamed city? Oh wait, that'd involve EFFORT.

Look, I'll defend Bendis a lot to a lot of people. He's the creator that got me back into comics through Sam & Twitch. I love Fortune & Glory for its cheap laughs. I totally loved Jinx and Goldfish. I still think that up until issue 50, USM wasn't half as bad as people make it out to be. But Powers is easily the worst written book he's ever done in spite of some of the brilliant ideas present in stuff like "The Sellouts" and "Forever". But 'ideas' do not excuse bad writing.

Oh, and I like Oeming.
 
Last edited:
Friday

Friday

Well-Known Member
Wade_Wilson said:
I got turned off by the horrid art. Who's the artist on the book?
Click to expand...

Omening. And I really love the simplicity of his art. His clean pseudo-animated style tells stories very well.

I could never get into powers, and damn did I try. I mean its a police procedural set around dealing with superheros. Sounds like its right up my alley, but OurChair pretty much hit on my dislikes for the book, more so the plot points than the editing mistakes.
 
E

E

Moderator
Excelsior Club
ourchair said:
The first ICON arc was only enjoyable if you read the entire Image run, 60% of which was complete drivel.
Click to expand...

That's funny, because right before Bendis took it to Icon I asked him directly, via his message board, if it was necessary to read the first volume in order to enjoy it or get what's going on. he said no, and in fact was pretty rude about it.

I didn't have a clue what was going on.

So TOG - blame Bendis, not me.
 
thee great one

thee great one

Master of TOG-fu.
E said:
That's funny, because right before Bendis took it to Icon I asked him directly, via his message board, if it was necessary to read the first volume in order to enjoy it or get what's going on. he said no, and in fact was pretty rude about it.

I didn't have a clue what was going on.

So TOG - blame Bendis, not me.
Click to expand...

I'll tell him at Philly.
 
ourchair

ourchair

Well-Known Member
I'll be fair and say that I guess you could enjoy ICON Powers Volume 1 if you read Image Volume 1, but the fact is that the twit didn't even bother to reintroduce the characters and current events or premise within, which I think was a fatal mistake for a 'relaunch'.

E said:
That's funny, because right before Bendis took it to Icon I asked him directly, via his message board, if it was necessary to read the first volume in order to enjoy it or get what's going on. he said no, and in fact was pretty rude about it.
Click to expand...
As a long-time reader of Bendis, I can tell you that he has a very bad habit of saying "everyone can appreciate it" or "it stands on its own" when that's actually complete balderdash.

And with regards to his fan interactions, I never liked his 'humorously abrupt' manner of responding. It can be funny, but I think it's not as consistently funny to 'everyone' as he --- or the people who write his Wikipedia entry --- thinks it is.
 
E

E

Moderator
Excelsior Club
ourchair said:
As a long-time reader of Bendis, I can tell you that he has a very bad habit of saying "everyone can appreciate it" or "it stands on its own" when that's actually complete balderdash.

And with regards to his fan interactions, I never liked his 'humorously abrupt' manner of responding. It can be funny, but I think it's not as consistently funny to 'everyone' as he --- or the people who write his Wikipedia entry --- thinks it is.
Click to expand...

His dickery is well documented.
 
TwilightEL

TwilightEL

Well-Known Member
I... I genuinely can't tell whether this book is good or not. I'm not even sure if I enjoy it. It's like it exists in a vacuum for me. I've read almost all of the series and I can't make a value judgment on it. There are a few things that will make me roll my eyes, like the stupid random club rants, and there are a few things I'll like, like Christian telling the girl how to avoid upskirt and the superhero/villain teamup to get notoriety but... I really can't tell how I feel about it.
 
ourchair

ourchair

Well-Known Member
TwilightEL said:
I... I genuinely can't tell whether this book is good or not. I'm not even sure if I enjoy it. It's like it exists in a vacuum for me. I've read almost all of the series and I can't make a value judgment on it. There are a few things that will make me roll my eyes, like the stupid random club rants, and there are a few things I'll like, like Christian telling the girl how to avoid upskirt and the superhero/villain teamup to get notoriety but... I really can't tell how I feel about it.
Click to expand...
I used to feel the same way --- there're elements of it I find that are really smart, but then other elements that were just completely juvenile --- to the point of making me feel similarly undecided about my feelings, but now that I've stopped actively collecting it I look at my trades and hate them.

I think I tend to hate it more because people put it on a pedestal above his mainstream Marvel work, when honestly I find that giving him the free reign that comes with a creator-owned superhero work is just license to let him be an idiot.

But uh... Calista is HOT.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Top