Scott Pilgrim (spoilers!)

The Comic Board - Collecting, Buy, Sell, Trade & Comic News, Reviews & Discussion

Help Support The Comic Board:

Re: Scott Pilgrim

so i just finished rereading them for the hundredth time, and now im finally getting a little suspicious of Kim Pine.

The magical demon guy who captured Kim in High School to lure Scott is obviously Gideon... He looks too similar to the gentleman in the shadows at the end of volume 3 to be a coincidence...

Also there was that whole thing about Kim having a date, then saying she stayed home scrapbooking... Plus she clearly resents Scott's being in a relationship with Ramona.

Yeah... Maybe im just exhausted, but SOMETHING is going on.
 
Re: Scott Pilgrim

Really? I thought that Kim and Ramona were getting kind of buddy-buddy there at the end of vol. 3, though I do agree that something big is going to happen with her.
 
Re: Scott Pilgrim

i -do- hope she stays good, but I also think she has some connection to Gideon, and that Gideon was the guy who captured Kim in High School.
 
Re: Scott Pilgrim

Amazon says November 14th

O'Malley says either Nov 14th, or Nov 7th... but its all finished and being edited and printed right now...

Just a few more weeks...

If it comes out the 14th, it'll coincide with the release of League of Extraordinary Gentlemen: The Black Dossier. Thus making that the coolest comic book day of 2007.
 
Re: Scott Pilgrim

Scott Dot Ning! Bryan Lee O'Malley's brand spanking new Scott Pilgrim Discussion Board!

From the Speculation thread:

Dr.James (who is ME) said:
I think we're going to find out what happens when Scott gets beaten for the first time in a long time. I think they're building that up with Simon Lee (who did seem to be Gideon, just in the way BLO'M handled him at the end of volume three... but now that people are pointing out that its probably misdirection, and the fact that Gideon would be best waiting to show up until one of the later volumes, but im not sure). We'll find out soon enough.

I predict we'll finally get a little more backstory on Ramona (who I am definitely getting some Katchoo from Strangers in Paradise vibes from), but not the bits that involve Gideon quite yet... Maybe more about her college years. The fact that Scott knows so little about Ramona comes up in the preview on the site, so I assume that's where the trouble in their new relationship will begin... Trouble that a certain Lisa Miller might show up to use to her advantage. Plus Lisa could turn out to be another person for Ramona to fight.

One of the Seven Evil Ex-Boyfriends will be Lawrence Pilgrim. Cuz that would be awesome. Brother vs. Brother battle = wonderful... Plus we'd get more story on where he's been all this time.

I'd also like lots more Wallace in his capacity as Scott's mentor-type person. Maybe find out what he does for money.
Click to expand...

Bryan Lee O'Malley said:
Some of your theories are totally right, and some are totally wrong!

Hee hee hee.

Volume 4 will help you out, I think.
Click to expand...

He didn't respond to anyone else's speculation, cuz I am extra special.

:D :D :D :D :D

It is awesome to be able to speculate about Scott Pilgrim somewhere, because there are only like three people here who read the damn book, even though its the best Indy comic ever.
 
Last edited:
Re: Scott Pilgrim

Dr.Strangefate said:
It is awesome to be able to speculate about Scott Pilgrim somewhere, because there are only like three people here who read the damn book, even though its the best Indy comic ever.
Click to expand...

I read it and enjoy it. For some reason I still find it hilarious that Ramona was wearing Mr. Men shoes.

Look forward to vol. 4.
 
Re: Scott Pilgrim

Dr.Strangefate said:
Scott Dot Ning! Bryan Lee O'Malley's brand spanking new Scott Pilgrim Discussion Board!

From the Speculation thread:





He didn't respond to anyone else's speculation, cuz I am extra special.

:D :D :D :D :D

It is awesome to be able to speculate about Scott Pilgrim somewhere, because there are only like three people here who read the damn book, even though its the best Indy comic ever.
Click to expand...

That is awesome! I completely agree with the Lawrence theory.
 
Re: Scott Pilgrim

I am already the second highest poster on Scott Dot Ning (BLO'M is the top poster).

Anyone who likes this should join, since BLO'M posts there pretty much all the time... Its a great chance to actually have a dialogue with a creator about his work while the membership is still relatively low.
 
Re: Scott Pilgrim

MY ****ING COPY HASN'T COME IN THE ****ING MAIL AND IM JUST ABOUT READY TO GO CRAZY!!!

But yeah... It's out...
 
Re: Scott Pilgrim

Just read the hell out of Volume Four, which I will reread extensively when I get back to school and have all of the volumes together and whatnot...

PLUSES:
Lisa Miller was awesome (Not ALL smokers are evil in the Pilgrimverse)
Scott was totally awesome
Knives' Dad is kickassimification embodied
KNIVES AND KIM TOTALLY MAKE OUT! OMG!
COLOR PAGES!!!!

MINUSES:
Should have had more Wallace... But I am madly in love with Wallace, so I guess i'm a little biased.
The Evil Ex-"Boyfriend" was a little underwhelming, but the final battle was totally kickass and awesome

AWESOME/10

(Awesome is situated somewhere beyond countable numbers)

...

I want Volume Five now please...
 
Re: Scott Pilgrim

Dr.Strangefate said:
Just read the hell out of Volume Four, which I will reread extensively when I get back to school and have all of the volumes together and whatnot...

PLUSES:
Lisa Miller was awesome (Not ALL smokers are evil in the Pilgrimverse)
Scott was totally awesome
Knives' Dad is kickassimification embodied
KNIVES AND KIM TOTALLY MAKE OUT! OMG!
COLOR PAGES!!!!

MINUSES:
Should have had more Wallace... But I am madly in love with Wallace, so I guess i'm a little biased.
The Evil Ex-"Boyfriend" was a little underwhelming, but the final battle was totally kickass and awesome

AWESOME/10

(Awesome is situated somewhere beyond countable numbers)

...

I want Volume Five now please...
Click to expand...

I agree 200%, Lisa Miller was an excellent character, the inclusion of the color pages completely surprised me and was awesome, Scott said the L-word and I loved the Evil Ex-"Boyfriend" reveal. Knives' dad was completely kickass, and the scene where he cuts through the street car and Scott and Kim escape through the subspace doorway is one of my favorites.

Once again I love how all of the main characters grow with each volume. Kim moves into a new house, Sex Bob-Omb starts to record (mostly through Stephen Stills efforts), Scott and Ramona have a fight and clear that hurdle, Knives gets over Scott, Wallace didn't do much but he stole every scene he was in, and Scott Pilgrim finally gets it together.

OMFG Kim and Knives making out!!
Even more OMFG, Knives and Stephen Stills!!!!!!!

I don't know why but every time I read this volume, I'm pumped up afterwards. Vol. 5 can't come soon enough.
 
Re: Scott Pilgrim

Just picked up Vol 1 and finished it. Tried not to read any spoilers for the future from this thread. I enjoyed it, but i thought it was odd that most of it was a real-world teen relationship story, then in the last act, with no warning, all the video-game/rock fantasy elements just... appear. Maybe the abrupt, matter-of-course introduction of those elements was the whole point? But because there was no precedent, I was a little more overwhelmed with WTF than i was with awesome. Still fun, though.
 
Re: Scott Pilgrim

Wallace Wells is my hero...

I had that avatar for over a year too. I'll prolly switch back to it in anticipation for Scott Pilgrim vol. 5.
 
Re: Scott Pilgrim

W00t!!

Holy crap. I just typed W00t and Firefox didn't underline it as being spelled incorrectly. I guess when you make it into the dictionary, you make it into the dictionary.
 
Re: Scott Pilgrim

Meh.

I mean, I love Michael Cera, and we all know how much I love Scott Pilgrim (I will give you a hint, I love it so bad that I dream about the characters sometimes), but NOTHING in Cera's work has shown that he has the exuberence to pull off the character of Scott Pilgrim. I can kind of see what sort of character they might turn him into, but Scott needs to be pure energy, and I sure as hell can't picture Cera in a fight scene.

So color me nervous.... I will definitely see it, but I will just have to see who else they cast in this.
 
Re: Scott Pilgrim

Mary%20Elizabeth%20Winstead2.jpg


Mary Elizabeth Winstead will play Ramona Flowers.
 
Re: Scott Pilgrim

I basically agree with everything DSF said about Cera being cast. I honestly wish they'd get somebody else; either a talented newcomer, or maybe Anton Yelchin. But hey, it's acting, right? Just because Cera doesn't have the track record for it, it doesn't mean he won't pull it off. I'm just worried about the fight scenes lacking credibility. But whatever.

Winstead is definitely not my first choice for Ramona. But I suspect she'll be able to sell the role convincingly enough.

I'm just gonna have to put my faith in Wright's ability to direct them, really. At least he's got a firm history of getting his cast to turn on the right kind of charm.

EDIT: Here's one authoritative report confirming Winstead as Ramona, in case anybody thought that might still be rumors/speculation: http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/hr/content_display/news/e3iddf6bb69274592b70ef8a3c006e3681f


.
 
Last edited:
Re: Scott Pilgrim

I think that whoever they cast as Wallace will make or break this movie.

I'm actually not being facetious here. He can't be a gay stereotype, he needs to be better looking than all of the other male characters (at least taking the most care of himself physically), he needs to be smart and calculating and be a good mentor/boss/friend figure all at the same time.

I can't think of any established actor who could pull it off who's in the age-group they seem to be casting here.

Casting Knives is also problematic. It'll be interesting to see what they do with her.

Also: Envy Adams should be played by Scarlett Johannsen.

...

Anyone who isn't reading Scott Pilgrim is ten kinds of lame.

EDIT: And The movie is now titled "Scott Pilgrim vs. The World"
 
Last edited:
Re: Scott Pilgrim

Anyone who liked Nextwave should be reading Scott Pilgrim.

Actually, everyone ever should read Scott Pilgrim, but especially those people.

Scott Pilgrim is AMAZING. I started reading with absolutely no idea what it's about. It starts off like a romance/drama/comedy and I thought it was slow, but good. Then events begin to unfold. Okay, it's a little bit like xkcd. I like that.

And then it descends into all-out Nextwave insanity. But despite all this, despite 64 hits and a bonus life and a half-ninja and vegan powers, it's realistic. These are people you know and awkward dirty rooms you've sat in with your exes (well, I'm not speaking from personal experience on that).

And DSF is right. Wallace Wells is king--but not in a way that makes you go "God, Scott sucks. Why isn't this about Wallace?" And he's not a perfect author avatar.

The insanity and the realism play off each other, striking a brilliant and wonderful balance between being like real life--boring and relatable--and being like Nextwave--made of awesome, but ultimately shallow.

CHAU DOWN!
 
Re: Scott Pilgrim

I picked up all four volumes last week. I haven't read Volume 4 yet, but. . .

Scott Pilgrim is, quite possibly, the best comic ever. Is it sad that I can relate to Scott? That I pretty much get all the video game references?
 

Similar threads

N
Realization about superhero comics
Replies
5
Views
820
[email protected]
N
stphylcccs
Adventure Time(line)
Replies
20
Views
3K
user 16960
U
B
Marvel Cinematic Multiverse Timeline
Replies
4
Views
661
Beamy11845
B
stphylcccs
Western Animated Comedy timeline
2 3 4
Replies
103
Views
8K
Gloryman
G
Pro Bot
Evil Dead Canonicity
Replies
1
Views
5K
Pro Bot
Pro Bot

Latest posts

Back
Top