They would keep the style originals and avoid horrific cgi like in the prequels. Remember Random's film making advise "Keep it simple". All too often people go overboard on cgi and they loose sight of what is important
At last someone here says what I keep saying about cgi.
I liked the preqels because they are star wars. Episode III IMO is the best of the 6 thou.
but yes I'm sick of people doing just because cgi can do it. It leads to horrible movies that look good but are all flash no substance. One of the many things I hate about films today is they make a film just show what they can do CGI wise.
Now cgi is important to films like shrek or turtles as they are made of it but other films go sooooo over the top with it and have so little story they are basically big budget cartoons with live action added (kinda like the opposite of rodger rabbit)
People say a lot of things. Doesn't mean they always go by what they said. And if it worked for Empire Strikes Back, why wouldn't it work for this if say it was done and Lucas wasn't directing?
Episode V was written by Lucas so it was still HIS story.
How is it any different as a show or direct to DVD? Only difference is that it's not in theatres, and a show would run longer. Do you think Lucas would direct it? If he doesn't, guess what? It's another person directing like if someone else directed it if it was a movie, if it actually happened! OH NOES!
Difference is Shows and tv shows fall in to same category as Comics. That's EU stuff and so has more lean way as if anything is done wrong to the movies they just except its non-cannon and a cool story
First rule you always need to learn is that you will never, NEVER please everyone. Fan or not. And how would that make it any different if it was a show? You think everyone would automatically fall in love with it?
Again real fans are more open to allow EU with mistakes or different feel as it is not quiet the same thing as film. You are right you wont please everyone. but doing the way I said = 10% of real fans pissed off at most. Way you said 20-30% of real fans pissed off.
That will lose Lucas thousands of money and I don't think he wants that.
You're a very good debater. You should earn a prize.
You too. I love how you just respond with a question. Or your way of answering.
Also reason I said I really don't want to have this discussion is every star wars site , fan club , chat room ect. that i am a member off always some star wars noob says "lets do a film based on *insert game or comic* and when you tell them all the thousands of reasons why it won't work they don't listen
like i'm sure you hate comic noobs saying "So is superman faster than the flash?" or some other thing you've heard and debated so much you almost know what the other will reply.
