The Comic Board - Collecting, Buy, Sell, Trade & Comic News, Reviews & Discussion

Help Support The Comic Board:

Zombipanda said:
ooooooooooh.....

Really?

Yeah the guy who sells me comics told me. He said that dc wanted justice league to be the first number one they put out, but when the number 2's started coming they moved it to a week three comic.
 
Yeah the guy who sells me comics told me. He said that dc wanted justice league to be the first number one they put out, but when the number 2's started coming they moved it to a week three comic.

I see!!

Well, don't let anyone ever say I'm not willing to admit when I'm wrong.

I stand corrected on my perfectly sincere comment!

;) Also, welcome to the forum.
 
Zombipanda said:
I see!!

Well, don't let anyone ever say I'm not willing to admit when I'm wrong.

I stand corrected on my perfectly sincere comment!

;) Also, welcome to the forum.

Haha thanks
 
Can someone please explain to me how swamp thing is a great comic? I just can't see it being a monthly comic.

The art's incredible and it's building up to be a great horror book. Scott Snyder tends to be a great writer in general so that helps too.
 
Can someone please explain to me how swamp thing is a great comic? I just can't see it being a monthly comic.

It's a comic with a prestigious history, both as a flagship of the Vertigo line and as one of the early magnum opi of Alan Moore.

There's a dense history open to exploration, allowing, hypothetically, years of storytelling.

It's being written by one of comics' biggest rising stars, a guy who's become both a critical darling for his work at Vertigo (American Vampire) and a reliable moneymaker for publishing the best selling book of the 52 relaunch (Batman), outstripping even Justice League, which is supposed to be the flagship and which was fittingly packed with DC's two big "all stars".

It also happens to be one of the better books of the launch. And given Snyder's status as a critical and commercial darling, I doubt it will be cancelled even if sales aren't that hot. Honestly, I can't see how thing book could fail.

That said, given how everything seems to be stacked in this book's favor, I'm actually a little disappointed with it. It's good, definitely, and easily better than most of the standard fare being published, but it wasn't as great as I expected it to be, given the pedigree. I'll continue buying it, and I think it's a good book, but I'm really the quality improves and we see Snyder weaving more and more depth into the story. I have hope, though. I trust the guy.
 
rvolker1204 said:
Can someone please explain to me how swamp thing is a great comic? I just can't see it being a monthly comic.

Are you talking specifically about the current series? Because if you have doubts they can run this as a monthly then, yeah, check out Alan Moore's run if you haven't.

Did you read it and not like it, or didn't get the hype?
 
E said:
Are you talking specifically about the current series? Because if you have doubts they can run this as a monthly then, yeah, check out Alan Moore's run if you haven't.

Did you read it and not like it, or didn't get the hype?

No I haven't read it, I wanted to know what was so great about it before I bought it
 
I didn't find the new SWAMP THING to be particularly good. The only 52 I actually enjoyed was ANIMAL MAN.
 
The second issue of Swamp Thing is an improvement from the mess of the first issue of Swamp Thing (which I thought was a mess) and reminds me of Alan Moore's story.

Hawk and Dove disappointed me immensely. I wanted to give it a shot, but the art is horrendous and story is so hokey. Look out for the new tag team of Condor and Swan! Who's next? Egret and Swallow?
 
Just read SWAMP THING #1 & 2, which were both great, along with the first 3 issues of Snyder's Image mini SEVERED. (Anyone else reading that?) Next up: ANIMAL MAN #1 & 2.
 
Out of curiosity, what books aren't you guys seeing from DC right now that you'd like to pick up month-to-month?
 
Out of curiosity, what books aren't you guys seeing from DC right now that you'd like to pick up month-to-month?

Batwoman (obviously)
Wonder Woman
Animal Man (duh)
Swamp Thing
Stormwatch
Justice League Dark (still hate the title)
Action
Batman
Voodoo
I, Vampire
Frankenstein

Those are my DC pull list.

Others I may pick up as trades, like; Superboy, Supergirl, Lantern books and a few others.
 
Both of you need to read the question again.

My answer: Shazam!
 
Last edited:
Both of you need to read the question again.

My answer: Shazam!


I did misread it, and I have to disagree, historically DC has shat all over Captain Marvel, only the Kids' title (Billy Batson) and Smith's Monster Society have been worth reading. I'd rather not have my heart broken... again.

I'd love to see Renee Montoya in something, maybe in a new GCPD book. Alternatively, would love a Question book as well. Oooo... maybe a new Weird Wars book, or a Morrison penned Seven Soldiers ongoing.
 
GCPD, definitely. I would have more interest in DC if the 52 were more well-rounded and represented different genres better. I'm disappointed it hasn't.
 
GCPD, definitely. I would have more interest in DC if the 52 were more well-rounded and represented different genres better. I'm disappointed it hasn't.

Yeah, it's pretty much Superheroes and Horror. Altho, historically, that's what made DC, so maybe it's a good idea.


Still want a GCPD book...
 
I think they screwed the pooch by not diversifying more. If you want to expand your market, you need to expand your genres and actually market it to people outside the community. No one should be surprised when DC puts out a few non-superhero books, only markets them to their base, and then they don't sell. Big ****ing surprise.

I want a Shazam! book too. Give it to Brian Clevinger. Sold.
I also wouldn't mind seeing a police procedural. GCPD's been done though. I think something based in Flash's city (the name of which eludes me right now) could be pretty fascinating, as could one set in the new take on Metropolis.
As mentioned above, I'd like to see Ba and Moon take on OMAC.
Secret Six
Sarge Steel in a 1940's pulp period piece.
And some sort of space opera would be nice to round everything out.
 
Loved The Shade No 1!!! Splash page to remember at the end of the story...

Batman and Robin No 2...a little better, less sappy, more realistic...

Ressurection Man No 2... Losing initial interest...really? Turned into water??!?

Batwoman No 2...The best of the batch so far....powerful storytelling, amazing art, loved the Batman - Batwoman sequence...

More tomorrow ( I hope)...
 

Latest posts

Back
Top